“There’s No Way I Can Lose My Case at Trial”

I’ve heard these words many times from clients who feel certain about the strength of their case. Unfortunately, that certainty doesn’t reflect the reality of a trial. Courtrooms are pressure cooker environments. Trials are shaped by unpredictable witnesses, judges, and juries. No matter how strong your evidence may seem, no lawyer can guarantee a specific outcome.

What you can do is increase your odds of success. That means building the strongest, most persuasive case possible—and going into trial with your eyes open about the risks.

Witnesses

Preparation matters, but witnesses are human. Once they raise their right hand and swear to tell the truth, even the most well-prepared witness can say something completely unexpected. The stress of the courtroom, the pressure of cross-examination, or even nerves alone can derail the best preparation.

Judges

Judges are experienced, but they are also human. Even when you have appeared before a judge enough times to anticipate how they may lean, judges can still surprise you. They may see an issue differently, or they may make a mistake—that’s why appellate courts exist.

Juries

In a civil trial, six people are chosen to decide your case. You have only a brief window during jury selection to learn anything meaningful about how they think or make decisions. Jury selection is an art, not a science, and there is no formula that can predict how a juror will rule. Their life experiences, biases, and perceptions all play into the verdict in ways no one can fully anticipate.

The Hard Truth About Trials

“I’ve seen weak cases win and strong cases lose” is not just a saying among trial lawyers—it’s the reality. A wise litigant weighs the strength of their case while also recognizing the unpredictability of trial. Only then can you make an informed decision about whether to proceed, knowing there are no guarantees once you step into the courtroom.

Taking the Next Step

If you’re facing a business dispute, don’t leave your future to chance. Our firm helps business owners evaluate their risks, strengthen their position, and make informed decisions about trial and settlement. Call us today to book a consultation and start building a strategy designed to maximize your odds.